When
the developers of Home Town NRH proposed the project in 1999,
they made a bold claim.
The 330-acre neighborhood would not only provide a focal
point for North Richland Hills and its sometimes-disconnected
subdivisions. It would also use natural shade, street layout
and other features to reduce the outdoor temperature by as
much as 5 degrees.
Four years later, substantial parts of the project have
been built. The developer still makes that claim on its Web
site. And although Home Town NRH may have succeeded in creating
a more closely knit community, it's still unclear whether
it is cooler than the rest of the Metroplex.
"Will we be cooler than the typical suburban development?
My opinion is, yeah," said Dan Quinto, one of the project's
developers. But he said: "How far along that road are
we? Is it measurable?"
Hashem Akbari, an expert on urban climates at the Berkeley
National Laboratory in California who helped design the neighborhood,
was more upbeat.
"Once this whole thing is complete, I would not be
surprised to see a few degrees cooler neighborhood, a more
comfortable neighborhood than the surrounding neighborhoods,"
said Akbari, with the Lab’s Heat
Island Group.
Home Town NRH was one of several new-urbanist projects proposed
in Northeast Tarrant County during the late 1990s. New urbanism
calls for upending the traditional car-dependent suburb and
mixing homes, offices and shops to create a more people-friendly
neighborhood.
Similar projects have popped up nationwide, but only a few,
including Home Town NRH and Civano in Tucson, Ariz., were
designed specifically to reduce heat.
Akbari, who helped design both projects, believes that cities,
with their huge expanses of pavement, trap heat and create
a virtual island that stays hotter than the surrounding countryside.
He suggested using age-old techniques to cool the air naturally:
"It's only been very recently, with the advent of air
conditioning, that these measures have not been paid much
attention," Akbari said. In Spain and other countries
along the Mediterranean coast, houses are often built around
a central courtyard with a fountain, which provides the same
type of cooling as the fountains in Home Town NRH, he said.
Gail Prososki-Marsland of Tucson, whose company, Solar Built,
worked on some of the houses in Civano, said many are more
energy-efficient than a typical house. But it's unclear whether
the outdoor temperature is lower.
The developer experimented with a pavement made of crushed
rock held together with an enzyme compound instead of concrete
or asphalt. It was significantly cooler, but it had problems
holding up under truck traffic.
"The idea was good," she said. "They later
came back and had to blacktop part of it. There was definitely
a temperature difference."
Quinto said it may take years to gauge the final effect
in Home Town NRH. Several dozen houses have been completed,
but none of the commercial buildings have been started. The
fountains have only recently been installed, and the trees
are still small.
Johnna Cook, who moved to a corner lot in Home Town NRH
in April, said she loves the neighborhood, regardless of whether
it is cooler than the rest of the Metroplex.
Her electric bill is lower, even though her new house is
bigger than her old house, but she attributed that to better
insulation.
On a recent sweltering afternoon, her front porch was mercifully
shady. And, she said, it's a great vantage point for meeting
the neighbors. The houses have small back yards, which makes
it more convenient for neighbors to congregate in common areas.
"I know a lot of them because they walk past here,"
she said. That's a big change from her old neighborhood, where
the neighbors tended to stay indoors.
"I lived there 12 years, and I didn't know all of them,"
she said.
It isn't clear whether the narrow streets help control the
temperature, she said, but they definitely help control the
traffic.
As for the fountains, she said: "The sound's nice.
I don't know about cooling anything off."
Mike Lee, (817) 685-3858 [email protected]